Juana of Castile and Her Madness

by Heather R. Darsie

Juana la Loca, or Joanna the Mad, was the elder sister of Catherine of Aragon and sister-in-law to Henry VIII of England. Juana was born on 6 November 1479, a daughter of the formidable Isabella of Castile and Isabella’s husband Ferdinand of Aragon. Juana was known during her lifetime as Juana of Castile.  Juana married Philip von Habsburg, known as the Handsome, in 1496. Juana was 16 years old.  This union birthed the Spanish portion of the Holy Roman Empire through Juana’s and Philip’s sons.

Juana of Castile Prayer Book

Page from a choirbook for Philip the Fair and Juana of Castile (ca. 1504-6). Brussel, Koninklijke Bibliotheek, Ms. 9126; held by AlamireFoundation.org.

Juana went on to have six children with her husband, four girls and two boys. Both boys became Holy Roman Emperors as Charles V and Ferdinand I.  Juana’s four daughters married well, too. Eleanor married a King of Portugal and the King of France, Isabella married the King of Denmark, Mary married the King of Hungary and Bohemia, and Catherine married a King of Portugal. Mary was widowed at a young age, and went on to become her brother Charles V’s regent for the Low Countries during most of her life.

Juana was an intelligent young woman and, like her sisters, received a considerable education for the time-period. It was reported that Juana could speak the three main languages of the Iberian Peninsula, along with Latin and French. As a girl, Juana was expected to marry well. She was likely not taught anything about statecraft, military strategy, or politics. She was the third child of Isabella and Ferdinand, and the second daughter.

Juana of Castile Triptych

Wings from the Last Judgement Triptych of Zierikzee, by the Master of Afflighem, showing Philip von Habsburg and Juana of Castile c. 1500, held by the Royal Museums of Fine Arts of Belgium.

Juana was never expected to be Princess of Asturias, a title for the heir apparent to the throne of Aragon. This similar to the English title of Prince or Princess of Wales. It was never expected that Juana would become Queen of Spain. After all, Juana had two older siblings, her sister, Isabella and brother Juan. Juan sadly died in 1497 at the age of 19, possibly of tuberculosis. Isabella died in 1498. Juan’s only daughter was still born; Isabella died shortly after giving birth to her son Miguel. Miguel died in 1500 before he turned 2-years-old.

This succession of deaths quickly catapulted Juana to her new position. Juana’s husband Philip, perhaps somewhat insolently, declared Juana and himself Princes of Castile. This was seen as a slight to the memory of Juana’s recently deceased brother.  Juana’s mother, the formidable Catholic Monarch Isabella, passed away in 1504. This left the throne of Castile and Leon to Juana. She inherited the Kingdom of Aragon from her father upon his death in 1517.

In 1504 Juana started exhibiting signs of mental instability when her mother, Isabella, was stricken with a fever. As was seen throughout her lifetime, Juana was not eating or sleeping when her mother fell ill. After visiting with her mother, Juana wished to join her husband in Flanders, which would mean she would have to travel through France at a time when France and Castile were at war. When she was prevented from leaving for Flanders, twenty-four-year-old Juana flew into a rage. One must keep in mind that Juana was grieving the loss of her mother, whom she loved very much, and that Juana already had four children, the eldest of whom turned six years old on 15 November 1504, days before Isabella died on 26 November 1504. Juana’s behavior was later seen as a mark of mental instability.

Perhaps one of Juana’s most notorious, lurid displays of mental instability occurred when her husband died in September of 1506.  Already known to fly into jealous rages over her husband’s mistresses, even reportedly going so far as to attack at least one, Juana refused to part with her deceased husband for a disturbingly long time. Quite pregnant, Juana traveled with her husband’s body from Burgos to Granada, where he was to be buried. This is a distance of 668 kilometers, which would take 6.5 hours to drive in a car. Juana was said to have opened her husband’s casket to embrace him and kiss him.

Juana of Castile

Possibly Juana of Castile, artist and museum Unknown.

Unfortunately, Juana’s husband Philip spread rumors about her madness when he was still alive. Her behaviors after his death may have reinforced the rumors of her madness. Juana’s son Charles, who became the Holy Roman Emperor Charles V, eventually took over from Juana as regent, and then, king. In 1509 Juana was either placed in, or retired to, the Royal Monastery/Convent of Santa Clara in Tordesillas, Castile. Charles forbade Juana any visitors. She died in 1555, at the age of 75. Juana outlived all of her siblings, including Catherine of Aragon. Juana’s son Charles died himself in 1559, only a few years after his abandoned mother.

Was Juana truly mad? Was she undermined by her husband or son? Juana’s maternal grandmother, Isabella of Portugal, supposedly also suffered from mental illness and was sent to a convent. Juana’s grandson Carlos and great-granddaughter Maria of Austria, Duchess of Jülich-Cleves-Berg, reportedly also went mad. It is thought that Juana may have suffered from a wide range of mental illness, including schizophrenia and depression. However, it does seem that her behaviors escalated in response to the series of deaths her family experienced in the 1490s and 1500s. Juana’s siblings and nephew died in the later 1490s, her mother died in 1504, and her husband in 1506. Juana was frequently pregnant or recovering from childbirth throughout her short eight-year marriage, at a time when she was mourning the loss of her family members. On top of that, Philip was known to have many mistresses.

Both Philip the Handsome and Charles V had a lot to gain from Juana being declared unfit. She was also sent, or perhaps banished, to a convent by her son and not allowed any visitors for the rest of her life. So was Juana mad, or was she the victim of ruthless individuals in her life? What do you think?

Love learning about the Early Modern period? Are you interested in Tudor history or Women’s history? Then check out my book, Anna, Duchess of Cleves: The King’s ‘Beloved Sister’, a new biography about Anna of Cleves told from the German perspective!

UK Hardcover

 UK Kindle

US Hardcover

US Kindle

Please check out my new podcast, Tudor Speeches.

You Might Also Like

  1. The Four Wives of Philip II
  2. Mary, Queen of Scots: What a Difference Two Years Can Make
  3. The White Rose
  4. The Armada is Coming!
  5. Gloriana’s Rainbow: Elizabeth I and the Rainbow Portrait

 

 

 

Sources & Suggested Reading

  1. “Tordesillas, More than Just Where Spain and Portugal Divided up the World.” http://www.spain.info/en_US/reportajes/tordesillas_mucho_mas_que_el_lugar_donde_se_repartio_el_mundo.html Retrieved 24 February 2017.
  2. Aram , Bethany. Juana the Mad: Sovereignty and Dynasty in Renaissance Europe. Baltimore: John Hopkins UP (2005).
  3. Espi Forcen, M.D., Fernando. “The Tragic Story of Joanna the Mad.” Journal of Humanist Psychiatry, Vol. 2, Iss. 2 (Spring 2014).
Advertisements


Categories: Women

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

4 replies

  1. Currently reading Gillian Fleming’s book on Juana. I do not believe for a moment that Juana was mentally unstable. The chroniclers do mention depression but Juana was intelligent and had learned from the best (her mother). She was also taught from a very young age to be subservient to the men in her life, to her own detriment. Even though she was the legal monarch of Castile, she was consistently thwarted in trying to rule her kingdom by her husband, her father and her son. They used the mental instability as a weapon against her so they could engage in a power grab. This is a very sad story.

    Liked by 1 person

Trackbacks

  1. Breaking Up is Hard to Do: Eleanor of Aquitaine and Henry II of England – Maidens and Manuscripts
  2. Two Battles, Two Queens, Two Speeches: Mary I and Elizabeth I – Maidens and Manuscripts

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: